The Book of Proverbs
(in Hebrew: ??????? Mishley
) is a book of the Hebrew Bible (the Christian Old Testament), included in the collected works known as the "Writings" or Ketuvim.
|
THE PROVERBS TICKETS
|
Title
The original
Hebrew title of the book of Proverbs is "Míshlê Shlomoh" ("Proverbs of
Solomon"). When translated into
Greek and
Latin, the title took on different forms. In the Greek
Septuagint (LXX) the title became "paroimai paroimiae" ("Proverbs"). In the
Latin vulgate the title was "proverbial", from which the English title of Proverbs is derived.
Authorship
The authorship of Proverbs has long been a matter of dispute. Solomon’s name appears in Proverbs 1:1, "The proverbs of Solomon the son of
David, King of Israel." There are also references within Proverbs to
Agur (30:1) and
Lemuel (31:1) as authors distinct from Solomon. These names are missing in the Greek translation of the
Septuagint. Medieval scholars used in the
Vulgate the Hebrew rendering of these two verses, and in their eyes the words "Agur" and "Lemuel" were but symbolical names of Solomon.
[1]
Solomon is often mentioned as someone who has extensive
wisdom in the Bible as well as in extra-biblical literature. However at the time of composition it was often the custom to place the name of the King or someone of prominence in writings in order to honor them, or to give those writings more prestige. In
1 Kings 4:29-34, 3000 proverbs and over 1000 songs are said to have come from Solomon and it is also said that people came from all over to hear the wisdom of Solomon. The general assumption is that Solomon was a part of the authorship to some extent, but that the book was not solely his work. Not only are the names "Agur" and "Lemuel" linked to other sections of the book, there are elements of disunity within the book that suggest more than one author.
Some of the authorship is attributed to "Men of
Hezekiah" (25:1), though it is stated that they simply transcribed the proverbs rather than writing them of their own accord.
In terms of the text itself there are at least eight specific instances where authorship is mentioned:
Hezekiah’s men)
| 30:1
| Agur son of Jakeh
|
| 31:1
| Lemuel (or his mother)
|
| 31:10-31
| author unstated
|
As for the eighth section there are scholars who consider the
poem at the end of the book vs. 10-31 as written by an unknown author. The attributions of authorship are as follows in accordance with the scriptures above; Solomon, Solomon, Wise Men, Wise Men,
Solomon (as copied by
Hezekiah’s men), Agur son of Jakeh, Lemuel (or his mother), and the unknown author. With this possibility it is speculated that the sections written by the Wise Men were studied by Solomon and added in and that they influenced his writing. With this possibility it is likely that there would be similarities in the section written by Solomon as well as the sections by the Wise Men. Studies of word usage have indicated that the highest percentage of commonalities are between the three Solomon sections. The next most common are the Wise Men sections, showing that they could have influenced Solomon’s writing, and the least commonalities were with the Agur, Lemuel, and the unknown author. A majority of critical scholars, including James L. Crenshaw, Roland E. Murphy and L.G. Perdue, hold to the belief that much of Proverbs was brought together from a time well after Solomon. However, many well respected theologians continue to attribute most of the book to Solomon, including J. I. Packer, John Piper, John F. MacArthur, and Albert Mohler.
Structure
- The Proverbs of Solomon (Proverbs 1-24)
- * Title and Prologue (Proverbs 1:1-7)
- * Main Text Divided Into Discourses (Proverbs 1:7-9:18)
- * Proverbial Sayings (Proverbs 10:1-22:16)
- * Thirty "Sayings of the Wise" (Proverbs 22:27-24:22)
- * Additional "Sayings of the Wise" (Proverbs 24:23-34)
- Proverbs of Solomon copied by the men of Hezekiah (Proverbs 24-29)
- Sayings of Agur (Proverbs 30)
- Sayings of King Lemuel (Proverbs 31)
- * Duties of a King (Proverbs 31:1-9)
- * Praise of the Virtuous Woman (Proverbs 31:10-31) [2]
Influences
There has been a consensus among scholars that there is a crossover of some Egyptian and Assyrian nature in the proverbs from The
Instructions of Amenemopet [3] and
Ahiqar.
[4]
Proverbs as wisdom literature
The book of Proverbs is referred to as
wisdom literature along with several others: the
Book of Job,
Ecclesiastes, the
Song of Solomon, and certain
Psalms, known as wisdom psalms. Among the
deuterocanonical books,
Ecclesiasticus and the
Wisdom of Solomon are
wisdom literature.
Throughout Proverbs, wisdom (or the wise person) is compared and contrasted with foolishness (or the fool). 'Fool' in Proverbs indicates one who is lacking in morality and uninterested in correction, not one who is merely silly or playful. Wisdom is held up as something worth effort to attain and the reader is told that it starts with the person of
Yahweh: "The fear of Yahweh is the beginning of wisdom."
[5]
Setting
It is difficult to pin the provenance of Proverbs down. Several suggestions have been made.
In the society of ancient Israel, the family played an important role in the upbringing and education of children. Some internal evidence hints to the use of Proverbs in a family setting; the phrase "my son" appears some 20 times throughout the book. The role of the mother is also listed some 10 times.
The name of Solomon stands in the title of the book, thus suggesting a royal setting. Throughout the Old Testament, wisdom is connected with the court.
It is possible practical and reflective wisdom was transmitted in a house of learning or instruction.
[6]
Messianic interpretations in Christianity
There are found in Proverbs, and other
wisdom literature, references to Wisdom as a personification. These have long been taken by Christian exegetes as references to Christ, who is called the wisdom of God by
Paul the Apostle(1 Cor 1:24). The first time Wisdom is personified is at Prov 1.20. In all these passages Wisdom is spoken of as a woman because the Hebrew(
chokhmah
) and Greek word(
sophia
) for “wisdom” is itself feminine.
[7]
The
King James Bible reads, in reference to wisdom in Prov. 8:22, that "
The LORD possessed me in the beginning of his way, before his works of old.
" The
Revised Standard Version reads “
The LORD created me at the beginning of his work, the first of his acts of old.
”
[8] Proverbs 8 has long been taken to refer to Christ, so whether or not the Hebrew ???(qanah) should be taken as "created" or as
"possessed" was used in the debate over the eternity of Christ. Both these meanings are used in the Old Testament but many contemporary scholars render it as "created".
[9] Proponents of "possessed" such as Kidner argue that it is absurd to think that God would need to create Wisdom, implying there was a time when he lacked Wisdom. Also, “Prov 8 starts from the indisputable commonplace that God existed before the start of time and ascribes the same precedence to wisdom.”
[10] The remainder of Prov 8 they argue, shows Wisdom taking a role in creation, and contrasts Wisdom with created things. However, understanding ??? as possessed leaves open the possibility that Wisdom should be understood here as a personification of an attribute of God rather an entity in its own right.
[11] The Hebrew ????('amown) in Prov. 8:30 is still a subject of debate among Bible scholars. 'Amown has been undestood as either: "artisan or master craftsman" which suggests that Wisdom is an active participant in creation, or as "nursling" which excludes any notion of Wisdom's active participation in creation.
[12] [13] [14]
It has been noted by some Christian exegetes that Col 1:15-16 is dependent on this chapter of Proverbs.
[15] The parallels in the roles of Christ and Wisdom, they argue lend credence to understanding qanah as possessed rather than created. They argue that "Wisdom was, before the Lord made even a particle of matter (verse 26) or gave order to creation (verse 29); Wisdom participated in the creation story. This strongly parallels the role of Christ in Colossians, where he is the “first-born of all creation” and in him were all things created. To add to the identification of Wisdom with Christ, we find that Wisdom was identified with the Greek concept of
logos, which was in turn identified with Christ."
[16]
Prov 8:22 was a crucial verse in the
Arian controversies of the fourth century CE. This verse was used both to support and refute the Arians' claims. Assuming first that Christ could be equated with the "Wisdom of God"(1 Cor. 1:24), the Arians argued that the son, like Wisdom was created, and to be a creature, whether the first or the most prominent of creatures, is to be subordinate to the creator. Those who formulated the
Nicean declaration that the Son was "begotten, not made" were inclined to translate ??? in Prov. 8:22 as "begot me" in order to argue that God and Christ were
cosubstantial.
See also
- As a dog returns to his vomit, so a fool repeats his folly
- Proverbs 31
References
- Dean, Matt (1913). "Book of Proverbs". Catholic Encyclopedia. http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12505b.htm
- adapted from Holman Bible Handbook on Proverbs
- ”Ancient Egyptian Literature, Volume II: The New Kingdom”, p146-163, Miriam Lichtheim, University of California Press, 1976, ISBN 0-520-03615-8
- The personification of Wisdom, Alice M. Sinnott, Society for Old Testament Study
- Proverbs 1:7, 9:10
- W. Dennis Tucker, "Literary Forms in the Wisdom Literature" In: An introduction to Wisdom Literature and the Psalms, FS Marvin E. Tate, ed. H. Wayne Ballard, 163-166
- Wade Johnston, Proverbs 8, 2004, 4.
- Revised Standard Version, Proverbs
- The personification of Wisdom, Alice M. Sinnott, Society for Old Testament Study, p 25
- Michael Fox, Proverbs 1-9: The Anchor Bible, (New York: Doubleday, 2000), 284.
- Who knows what is good? : a commentary on the Books of Proverbs and Ecclesiastes, Kathleen Anne Farmer, pp.53-54
- Parallel translation of Proverbs 8:30
- The personification of Wisdom, Alice M. Sinnott, Society for Old Testament Study, p. 29
- Who knows what is good? : a commentary on the Books of Proverbs and Ecclesiastes, Kathleen Anne Farmer, 55
- Ibid., 279.
- Ibid., 293.